Texas A&M University Kills Bats with Cruel Research

In the fall of 2008 we were alerted to a critical situation regarding cruel and unnecessary research being conducted by Dr. Christopher Quick at Texas A&M University. This research involves pallid bats, a small insectivorous bat about 3" in length. Four of these bats were injured during the research and can no longer fly well enough to be released. Thankfully -rather than being euthanized- these bats were retired to Bat World Sanctuary at the urging of one of the assistants involved in the research. An agreement was subsequently made for the retirement of the entire colony to Bat World when the research concluded. Unfortunately, we now have solid reason to believe that Dr. Quick has no intention of keeping his word, and feel the remaining bats will be used in this barbaric research until they die.

Please note that the eye witness account below contains graphic and heart wrenching testimony by individuals who were directly involved in this research, and who are now working to help free these bats from further suffering.

Beene' the first pallid bat to be
retired to Bat World Sanctuary from Texas A&M University.

 

   
  Eye WITNESS ACCOUNT:
   
  I am in need of your assistance with a critical matter involving a dwindling colony of pallid bats in a remote location in West Texas. These bats are continuing to be subjected to cruel experiments and housing once they are captured and placed into captivity. The following information outlines the years of cruelty that I personally witnessed.
CLICK HERE TO READ MY SWORN AFFIDAVIT
   
  Dr. Christopher Quick, a biomedical engineer, heads this research currently taking place at Texas A&M University, where he has been allowed to perform experiments on pallid bats for several years. He captures bats from a roosting site which the bats have been safely using for over 20 years. As a result of the removal of so many bats, a steady decrease in the population has occurred. In the past few years he has been allowed to take over 50 pallid bats, the majority of them females. Consequently, over 40 female pallid bats were not allowed to give birth to one pup a year for over four years, resulting in the loss of 160 bats within a four year time span. Many of these pups would have also reproduced during this time.
 
Excluding a few bats that died as a direct result of stress, these experiments are not entirely terminal. As a result, the bats have been subjected to an unnatural environment long-term, and forced to work during the day when they should be asleep. They are exposed to up to 15 different types of drugs, alcohol and periodic painful medical procedures without sedation. They are used in experiments for up to six hours per day. Witnesses have seen the bats struggling for so long during experiments that they eventually began urinating blood due to the stress of the experiment.

One of the worst aspects of this research involves a rectal probe. The rectal probe causes bleeding and tearing of the rectum and causes such high levels of stress that the bats often self mutilate by chewing on its own arm or rectum in order to try and free itself.  I witnessed bats urinating blood after this procedure, as well as rapid breathing and gnashing of teeth. The rectal probe is very rigid and made out of steel. While it is inserted using lidocaine, a short-term numbing agent, the bat is oftentimes in the box, laying in its back with the rectal probe inserted, for more than 30
 

A pallid undergoing an experiment under Dr. Quick's care. The bat is on its back, restrained in a Plexiglas box. The bat's wing is unnaturally stretched out and then held in place with weighted cotton swabs. The hot lens of the microscope is aimed at the delicate wing tissue for hours at a time, oftentimes causing burns.
(Photo credit: http://www.cvm.tamu.edu/cquick/BatLab/)

 
  minutes at a time. It is not uncommon for a bat to cry out during the entire procedure. The bat is placed into the box restrained, with the rectal probe inserted, then its body is heated to see how high the bats body temperature would rise. Recordings are taken to see how long it took the bat's body temperature to go back down to baseline temperature.  With the exception of Dr. Quick, everyone, including the grad students, hates this experiment.  When I was with Dr. Quick in the room, he would make the bat stay in the experiment box even after the experiment was over just to play around with the microscope. He would  look at the bats wing under the microscope, and I would tell him that the rectal probe cord was not long enough for him to be moving the bat around. A few times he moved the bat so much that he caused tension on the probe, causing the bat to cry out in agony. It was not until I stepped in and said enough was enough that he would grudgingly stop.
   
  The majority of Dr. Quick's literature states that the bat is placed in a box and is lightly covered with gauze during experiments. What is not explained is that the gauze is actually on the outside of the experiment box, and the bat itself is restrained in hard plastic. The bat is made to lie on its back in an unnatural position; a plastic plate is then inserted over the bats arm bone acting as an arm bridge preventing the bat from lifting its arm. The top of the box is then closed over the bat's body and the box is screwed shut with wing nuts. The bat's wing and fingers are then forced to lie open and flat, being held in place with q-tips that are secured at the end with silly putty. Several bats have been so stressed during these experiments that they chew through the skin and muscle
   
 

of their arms and actually began chewing on their arm bone just to try and free themselves from the experiment box.

Bats are also subjected to what is called a pressure box (photo right). This box is used in the same fashion as the one previously described, but it is air tight. The bat is subjected to pressure on its body to create vessel dilation in the vessels of its wings (similar to a hyperbaric chamber used by humans). This experiment runs on average 4 hours. This research has been allowed to continue despite the fact that these incidences were reported to Texas A&M University's Animals Compliance Committee, who choose to turn a blind eye to what was happening behind closed doors. It was even suggested by an Animal compliance chair member that "if the bats were still eating and hanging up-side down then they must be happy". When it was requested to retire bats that have been used for more than three years, another committee chairperson responded by saying, "how do you know the bats are unhappy in captivity, can you prove that they do not like taking part in this research?" Many pages can be filled with the concerns voiced by those alarmed by seeing injuries the bats have received during experiments, such as, wing tears, broken fingers, and many burned wings. Not to mention the lack of supervision and control Christopher Quick has over his lab.

   
  A large portion of the bats that currently remain in his captive colony at A&M have been there for over four years. They live in a room with concrete walls and meager roosts. While I was there, their only form of enrichment was being fed crickets, which they were allowed to hunt for on the ground of their enclosure, but that was stopped when facility managers received complaints about escaping crickets. To date, Dr. Quick has had his lab temporarily shut down and investigated two times so far due to valid complaints of misuse of bats and lack of supervision.
   
  Dr. Quick was absent the majority of the first two years in his research laboratory and relied solely on his graduate students for the output of data for the research. Additionally, there is compelling evidence that this research does not contribute in any way to science. Personally I only know of three papers that have been published, and two of them are by a PhD student. More importantly, almost every document from this research was done using computer models or lymphatic vessels in a bath, and not bats!  In fact, there are about 12 publications, all done with mathematical models and not bats, on Dr. Quick's faculty page. 

Two years ago, Dr. Quick collected 25 more bats from Valentine, Texas. While these bats were in quarantine, one of them succumbed to rabies. As a result, Dr. Quick ordered all of the remaining 24 bats euthanized, even after the CDC recommended the bats instead be spared and held in quarantine for another six months. Dr. Quick also had the option of retiring all 24 bats to Bat World Sanctuary where they would never be in close proximity to the public.

Instead, based on the opinion of
Vincent Gresham, A&Ms Clinical Veterinarian, these bats were euthanized with Carbon Dioxide (CO2) in a gas chamber, despite the fact that he had knowledge of credible literature stating bats have a high tolerance to CO2, and the use of CO2 to euthanize bats is considered inhumane. Dr Gresham gassed each bat, one by one. It took an average of one to three minutes for each bat to die; its body contorting in agony the entire time as it slowly suffocated to death. Each bat was then placed in a plastic zip-lock bag and placed into a refrigerator to await tissue sample collection to test for rabies. However, because of their high tolerance to CO2, some of these bats remained alive after being gassed and it was not known they were conscious until they woke up in agony while sliced open during necropsy. When it discovered that some of the bats were not fully deceased, their necks were broken. Results concluded that ALL 24 of those bats were found to be negative for rabies.

   
  TPWD is aware of the number of bats killed, as well as the current complaints, yet they continue to allow Christopher Quick to capture more bats every year. The wild colony in west Texas where these pallid bats roost used to be 3,000 + bats strong. Now, in large part due to Christopher Quick's continual harvesting of the colony over the last five years, there are less than 25 bats. The collection taking place today could very well wipe out the entire colony.
   
  Please help us take action against Texas A&M and Dr. Quick. This research must be stopped and the bats must be allowed to return to their home in the wild. Please e-mail the individuals below and urge them to end this unnecessary research and retire every bat in their possession to South Plains Wildlife Rehab, where it will be rehabilitated and allowed to return to its rightful place in the wild. Please also sign this petition and forward this web page to as many individuals and animal rights groups as possible.
   
  Christopher M. Quick: cquick@tamu.edu & cquick@cvm.tamu.edu
   
  Dr. Vincent Gresham, Clinical Veterinarian vgresham@vprmail.tamu.edu
   
  Dr. Glen Laine, Department Head over Dr. Quick: glaine@tamu.edu
  Dr. Glen Laine/Dr. Christopher Quick
Texas A&M University
Hwy 60
Department of Physiology and Pharmacology
College Station, TX 77845
   
  Betsy Browder, Comparative Medicine Program: bbrowder@cvm.tamu.edu
Texas A&M University
Comparative Medicine Program
Dr. Betsy Browder
Agronomy Rd.
College Station, TX 77845
   
  Director Dewey Kramer, Office of Animal Compliance: animalcompliance@vprmail.tamu.edu
Office of Research Compliance
Angelia Raines, Director & Olivia Ash Program Coordinator (Research Involving Animals)
750 Agronomy Rd
General Services Complex, Ste. 3501
1186 TAMU
College Station, TX 77843-3120
   
  Olivia Ash, Office of Animal Compliance: animalcompliance@vprmail.tamu.edu
Office of Research Compliance
Angelia Raines, Director & Olivia Ash Program Coordinator (Research Involving Animals)
750 Agronomy Rd
General Services Complex, Ste. 3501
1186 TAMU
College Station, TX 77843-3120
   
  Dr. Eleanor M. Green, Dean: emgreen@tamu.edu
Texas A&M University
Dr. Eleanor M. Green, Dean
College of Veterinary Medicine and Biomedical Sciences
750 Agronomy Rd.
College Station, TX 77845
   

 
FOUND A BAT? l LOCAL RESCUE l RESCUE CENTERS l ORPHAN RESCUE l BAT PROBLEMS l BAT HOUSES l MYTHS & FACTS l RABIES l SPECIES INFO l MOVIES l TOURS & EDUCATIONAL PROGRAMS l ONLINE TOUR l RESOURCES FOR TEACHERS l KIDS PAGE l BAT REHABILITATION TRAINING l INFO FOR BAT REHABBERS l ADOPT-A-BAT l MEMBERSHIPS l DONATE l SHOP! l ACTION ALERTSWALL OF SHAME  l WILD SANCTUARY l PHOTOS FOR PURCHASE
       HOME l CONTACT US

 Please see our copyright page for our policy regarding the use of our website material.